Home Lex Fridman Notes
Lex Fridman · 2023-02-15 · 2h 19m

Andrew Strominger: Black Holes, Quantum Gravity, and Theoretical Physics | Lex Fridman Podcast #359

Harvard physicist Andrew Strominger explains why black holes are mirrors, how they store information, and why now is a thrilling time for physics.

Andrew Strominger: Black Holes, Quantum Gravity, and Theoretical Physics | Lex Fridman Podcast #359
The guest

Andrew Strominger — Theoretical physicist at Harvard and a founder of the Black Hole Initiative. A pioneer of string theory whose work spans the holographic principle, black hole information, and the quantum structure of black holes; he co-authored the 'soft hair on black holes' paper with Stephen Hawking.

The gist

Strominger and Lex Fridman explore the deepest puzzles of modern physics, starting with what a black hole actually is and why even light cannot escape. The conversation moves through quantum gravity, the standard model, and string theory as a 'stepping stone' toward unifying quantum mechanics and general relativity. Strominger explains the holographic principle, how black holes store information on their surface area, and his collaboration with Hawking showing that black holes retain subtle 'soft hair' imprints. He also discusses photon rings around black holes, the Event Horizon Telescope image of M87, and the possibility of learning about black holes by treating them as hall-of-mirrors reflectors. The talk closes on emergent time and space, AI in physics, the origin of the universe, alien civilizations, and the responsibility of scientists.

Big reveals

  • Strominger says Einstein wrote a paper 25 years after predicting black holes arguing they don't exist, and jokes he wouldn't pass a student who turned that in.
  • Bets the farm that 100 years from now string theory will be seen as a stepping stone, not a final theory, and admits he doesn't believe it himself yet.
  • Explains the holographic principle: a black hole's information is proportional to its surface area, not its volume.
  • Reveals that if string theory had not reproduced the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, string theory itself would have been proven inconsistent.
  • Recalls Hawking turning down tea with Lady Gaga so they could spend another hour on their paper.
  • Says he honestly doesn't know if a theory of everything exists, and is confident we won't reach it in his lifetime.
  • States that time itself must ultimately be emergent, not fundamental.
  • Describes a black hole as a mirror that lets you see an infinite number of delayed copies of yourself.

Things worth remembering

  • Earth's escape velocity is about 11 km/s; the Moon's is only about 7 km/s; a black hole's reaches the speed of light.
  • Mercury's perihelion precesses once every 233 centuries versus Newton's predicted 231, the first crack in Newtonian gravity, measured by Le Verrier in 1859.
  • The standard model has been confirmed against experiment to 16 decimal places, which Strominger has stenciled on his office door.
  • The three simplest spacetimes are flat (Minkowski), negatively curved (anti-de Sitter), and positively curved (de Sitter).
  • John Wheeler coined both the term 'black hole' and the phrase 'black holes have no hair.'
  • A zero-energy 'soft' photon still carries angular momentum one, and a soft graviton angular momentum two, so they cannot simply be ignored.
  • The Event Horizon Telescope's famous 'donut' image of M87 was captured in 2018 and presented in 2019.
  • Ramanujan worked by guessing formulas and gathering a 'preponderance of evidence' rather than formal proofs.
  • The episode ends with Heisenberg's line that the universe is not only stranger than we think, but stranger than we can think.

Recommended in this episode

Books, products and media the guest or host genuinely endorsed here — with the buy link.

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

RecommendedMedia

Interstellar

Christopher Nolan (inferred)

“there's a wonderful movie um Interstellar and um in that movie you know Kip Thorne of course is a great theoretical physicist” — Andrew Strominger 01:54:04
Find it on Amazon