Home Tim Ferriss Notes
Tim Ferriss · 2022-01-04 · 2h 06m

Zen Master Henry Shukman — 20 Minutes of Calm and The Powerful World of Koans | The Tim Ferriss Show

Zen master Henry Shukman guides Tim Ferriss through a 20-minute somatic calming practice, then unpacks koans, kensho awakening, and how Zen training is verified.

Zen Master Henry Shukman — 20 Minutes of Calm and The Powerful World of Koans | The Tim Ferriss Show
The guest

Henry Shukman — An appointed teacher in the Sanbo Zen lineage and guiding teacher of Mountain Cloud Zen Center, who teaches mindfulness and awakening practices. He is also an award-winning poet and author of the Zen memoir 'One Blade of Grass.'

The gist

Tim Ferriss welcomes Henry Shukman back for a deep dive on Zen practice. The episode opens with a roughly 20-minute live somatic relaxation exercise in which Henry walks Tim through grounding attention in the body, softening tension, and 'allowing' difficult emotions rather than banishing them. The conversation then turns to koans, explaining their origin in Tang dynasty China, the meaning of the term 'public case,' and how koans are designed to puncture the sense of a separate self and reveal non-dual experience. Henry shares his personal kensho (awakening) experience while watching 'Who Framed Roger Rabbit,' describes the role of 'checking questions' and 'passing' koans, and discusses how to distinguish legitimate teachers from charlatans through accountable lineage structures. They also connect these states to psychedelic research, Donald Hoffman's work on perception, and the question of why awakening feels so benevolent.

Big reveals

  • Henry breaks down what 'allowing' and 'accepting' difficult emotions actually means in practice, starting with naming the feeling in a calm, kind, matter-of-fact internal voice ('to name it is to tame it').
  • Henry leads Tim through a live ~20-minute somatic calming practice: feeling hands, feet, and seat, slackening the jaw and tongue, then melting ease down through the whole body and softening around tension around the heart.
  • Koans mostly originated from awakened Chan/Zen masters in China's Tang dynasty (roughly 600-900 CE), and the term 'koan' translates to 'public case,' borrowed from legal precedent records.
  • There are about 1,700 classically recognized koans; Sanbo Zen uses roughly 420 across five collections, and Henry has been 'passed' on all of them at least twice, most multiple times.
  • Henry recounts his kensho experience: while watching 'Who Framed Roger Rabbit' and carrying a dinner plate, a cyclone of energy whipped through him, everything dissolved into vast empty space, and he was overwhelmed with love and gratitude.
  • 'Checking questions' (like 'show me mu,' 'how tall is mu,' 'how would you show it to a baby') let teacher and student confirm and deepen an awakening experience; after kensho these strange questions become easy to answer.
  • Henry explains the Sanbo Zen accountability hierarchy (assistant teacher, Zen teacher, associate master, authentic master with dharma transmission) as a safeguard against rogue, self-appointed 'masters.'
  • Henry agrees that some people we view as mentally detached may have had genuine kensho-like experiences but lacked any container or framework to integrate them, becoming lost and frightened.

Things worth remembering

  • Henry offers a simple four-emotion framework that is easy to remember: mad, glad, sad, afraid.
  • Tim looks up the koan etymology on Wikipedia: the characters literally mean 'public case,' referring to a public record of notable sayings and actions of Zen masters.
  • Zen was popular in the West during the psychedelic-influenced 1950s-80s, embraced by figures like J.D. Salinger, Allen Ginsberg, Jack Kerouac, and Alan Watts.
  • The three major koan collections are the Blue Cliff Record (100 koans, compiled 1028), the Book of Equanimity (100), and the Gateless Gate (48).
  • The classic starting koan 'mu' comes from master Joshu, who answered 'mu' (not) when asked whether a dog has Buddha nature; students sit with it softly on the breath like a mantra rather than thinking about it.
  • Henry's teacher Yamada Roshi was head of Mitsubishi's securities with around 30,000 employees and credited his successful career to the balance, clarity, and compassion his Zen practice gave him.
  • Tim notes that non-dual experiences correlate with down-regulation of the brain's default mode network, documented in psychedelic research at places like Johns Hopkins.
  • Tim recommends cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman (UC Irvine, Troland Award), his TED talk 'Do We See Reality As It Is?' and his book 'The Case Against Reality,' which argues perceived objects are like icons on a desktop.
  • Tim and Henry close on a language note: Greeks say 'it's all Chinese to me' as their equivalent of the English 'it's all Greek to me.'
  • Henry runs a broader meditation program called Original Love (originallove.org) that emphasizes the healing side of meditation alongside awakening, and has koan meditations on Sam Harris's app.

Recommended in this episode

Books, products and media the guest or host genuinely endorsed here — with the buy link.

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Guest’s ownBook

One Blade of Grass: Finding the Old Road of the Heart, A Zen Memoir

Henry Shukman (inferred)

“he has written of his own journey in his latest book one blade of grass subtitle finding the old road of the heart a zen memoir” — Tim Ferriss 00:04:13
Find it on Amazon
RecommendedMedia

Do We See Reality As It Is? (TED Talk)

Donald Hoffman (inferred)

“there's actually a great ted talk i want to recommend from a cognitive scientist named donald hoffman is a ted talk called do we see reality as it is and i highly recommend it to folks” — Tim Ferriss 01:53:16
Find it on Amazon
RecommendedBook

The Case Against Reality

Donald Hoffman (inferred)

“i just recently read his book the case against reality which is a sort of detailed dive it's not too long it's very readable he writes well” — Henry Shukman 01:54:48
Find it on Amazon
Guest’s ownBook

The 4-Hour Body

Tim Ferriss (inferred)

“my second book is a good example of this there are many things in that book that were highly controversial seemingly highly speculative but tested and measured multiple times” — Tim Ferriss 01:39:45
Find it on Amazon